This is only a preview of the July 1993 issue of Silicon Chip. You can view 37 of the 96 pages in the full issue, including the advertisments. For full access, purchase the issue for $10.00 or subscribe for access to the latest issues. Articles in this series:
Articles in this series:
Items relevant to "Build A Single Chip Message Recorder":
Items relevant to "Light Beam Relay Extender":
Items relevant to "Build An AM Radio Trainer; Pt.2":
Articles in this series:
Items relevant to "A Low-Cost Quiz Game Adjudicator":
Articles in this series:
Articles in this series:
|
The Keck observatory
biggest optical telescop
Recently commissioned on the Hawaiian
island of Mauna Kea is the world’s biggest
ever optical telescope. At 10 metres in
diameter, it is a great deal larger the previous
biggest, the Russian 6-metre reflector. This is
the story of the Keck Telescope.
Part 1: By BOB SYMES
The Hawaiian Islands, a group of
eight main and about 130 smaller
volcanic islands, are spread across
approximately 2600km in the Pacific Ocean and they rise some 5,500
metres from the floor of the central
Pacific Basin. The highest shield
mountain of this chain, Mauna Kea,
rises a 4,205 metres above sea level,
thus leading to the claim that it is the
highest mountain on earth, from base
to summit.
The altitude, combined with the
islands’ remoteness from major centres
of air pollution, and the prevailing
NE trade winds, which combine to
keep the weather relatively constant
and the air clear and dry, were major
considerations in choosing the site for
an observatory complex.
A prime observing site can more
than double the efficiency of any
telescope. This is a most important
consideration for any large telescope
where returns in scientific knowledge
need to be balanced against the huge
costs involved.
After a world-wide survey of possible sites in 1963 by Gerard Kuiner,
Mauna Kea stood out as the best
place in the northern hemisphere for
nighttime observation. The dry air at
this altitude, where more than 90%
of the atmospheric moisture is below
the instruments, is critical for infrared
observations, water vapour being the
primary attenuator of radiation in this
part of the spectrum.
4 Silicon Chip
Furthermore, Hawaii has a relatively small population and industry is
minimal. This leads to low light and
industrial pollution. The island also
has strict regulations affecting light
pollution with particular emphasis
on maintaining astronomical quality
of the night sky.
The summit of Mauna Kea is usually
above the inversion layer at night. The
layer of clouds that often form below
the summit on the windward side of
the island as a result act as a further
trap for light coming from Hilo 30km
away. Gases and aerosols emanating
from the occasionally active Kilauea
volcano which can affect spec
tro
graphic investigations are simi
larly
trapped by the inversion layer.
The stability of the air above the
inversion layer provides exceptional
optical resolution. The ultimate limitation to reso
lution on earth-based
telescopes is air stability, which invari
ably reduces the theoretical resolution
of the instruments them
selves. On
Mauna Kea, sub arc-second “seeing”
is normal, and on nights of good air
stability, resolutions of better than 0.5
arc-seconds are possible.
As a result of these considerations,
the Mauna Kea Observa
t ory was
founded in 1967, in affiliation with
the University of Hawaii. It has the
distinction of being the highest observatory in the world.
While conditions at the summit
are conducive to astronomical obser-
y – the world’s
pe
Taken under starlight, this
photograph of the Keck Observatory,
shows the enormous scale of the
mosaic telescope which has 36
hexagonal mirror segments kept in
alignment by computer control. Note
the man standing at one side of the
dome opening. Each mirror segment
weighs 400 kilograms, giving a total
mass of glass of 14.4 tonnes. The total
moving mass of the telescope is 270
tonnes.
vations, they are not quite so good to
the astronomers and technicians who
operate the facilities. At times the
weather can be severe, it is always
cold, and oxygen deficiency may be
a serious problem for some. For this
reason, people intending to work at
the summit need to acclimatise at a
mid-level facility at Hale Pohaku (9300
feet – 2800m) which was constructed
in 1982.
The University of Hawaii’s Institute
for Astronomy at the Manoa Campus in
Honolulu leases the land above 12000
feet (3650m) from the state of Hawaii,
and has dedicated it as a Science Reserve. In turn, the university provides
site facilities for other observatories
who wish to erect telescopes on the
summit.
Currently, there are eight telescopes
in operation on Mauna Kea plus one
in the commissioning phase – the W.
M. Keck telescope, the subject of this
article.
Neglecting the atmospheric restrictions referred to above, the angular
resolution of a telescope mirror (or
lens) depends solely on its diameter
and the wavelength being investigated. When the angular separation of
two stars is very small, it might be
imagined that by merely using enough
magnification, the stars would resolve
into two distinct images. Because of
diffraction effects within the optics
however, the image of each object
is not a point source, but a so-called
“Airy disc” whose diameter is 1.1 λ/D
radians, or 2.27 x 105λ/D arc-seconds
(D being the diameter of the objective
lens/mirror in centimetres).
If the two discs substantially overlap, any increase in magnification
merely gives a larger blur of light, but
does not result in separation of the
images. The stars will be just resolved,
however, when their Airy discs touch;
July 1993 5
light that we see left that object so
much earlier in the history of the universe. But at those vast distances, the
light reaching the earth is extremely
feeble and the apparent size of the
object is extremely small. So unless
an instrument can be built that can
gather as much of the available light
as possible, and of sufficient angular
resolution to show details of structure
etc, little information can be gleaned
from these objects.
Mirror problems
This model of the Keck telescope again shows the enormous size of the main
mirror. It is much larger than most domestic swimming pools and with a focal
ratio of f/1.75 (focal length divided by the diameter) it is deeply concave.
ie, when the centre to centre distance
is equal to the diameter of the disc.
Since D is the denominator, by increasing the diameter of the primary mirror/
lens, the diameter of the Airy disc will
be proportionately smaller, hence the
resolution will increase.
Last century, the noted British
amateur astronomer W. R. Dawes,
working with close double stars, gave
an empirical limit for the resolution of
a telescope in arc-seconds as 11.5/D
(the “Dawes Limit”). Strictly speaking,
this figure is wavelength dependent,
and refers to visible light of 5 x 105cm. Since it is a rule of thumb rather
than an exact physical formula, the
difference across the visible spectrum
is marginal, and can be neglected.
6 Silicon Chip
Wavelength does become important
however, when calculating the resolution in the infrared spectrum.
It follows therefore, where resolution is a factor, that the bigger a lens
or mirror can be made, the better. The
same goes for light gathering, although
in this case it is surface area that is important rather than diameter. The two
are not necessarily related. Doubling
the diameter of a circular mirror gives
four times the light-gathering power,
and a doubling in resolution.
Since researchers are forever trying to look further back in time, this
increase in light-gathering power
becomes of great importance. The
further away an object is, the further
back in time we can look, since the
The simple solution is to make bigger monolithic mirrors or lenses. But
the problems associated with them
ultimately become insurmountable.
Lenses supported only around their
circumferences sag under their own
weight. Once the sag becomes apprec
i
able, image-quality deteriorates to
a point where it becomes unusable.
Thus it is unlikely that large lenses
will ever again be used for astronomical work, although the existing ones
still perform admirably. The largest
of them, the 40-inch (1m) telescope at
Yerkes Observatory at William Bay in
Wisconsin, built by that most famous
of telescope builders, Alvin Clark,
and dedicated in 1897, is likely to remain forever the greatest of refracting
telescopes.
Larger mirrors are easier to design
and build, since they can be supported
from the rear, and since only one critical surface has to be figured to high
accuracy, as opposed to the four (or
sometimes six) surfaces that need to
be ground and polished for an achromatic objective lens. In addition, flaws
such as bubbles, inclusions and striae
in the glass of a mirror are acceptable,
whereas they would be intolerable in
a lens system.
Nevertheless, massive engineering
problems remain. The larger a mirror
becomes, the thicker it needs to be to
avoid flexure and hence the heavier
it becomes. The mounting becomes
bigger and heavier, along with the
cost, and finally there is reached a
point at which further gains are no
longer feasible. There is the additional
problem that the more mass of glass
there is, the longer it takes to reach
thermal equilibrium, and during this
time, image quality suffers due to local
distortions in the mirror.
As new materials and techniques
became available, the boundary of
what was feasible was pushed further
8MM VIDEO CASSETES
These 120-minute 8mm metal oxide video cassettes
were recorded on once for a commercial application
and then bulk erased. They are in new condition but
don’t have the record protect tabs fitted. The hole
in the upper right corner will have to be taped over.
$9 Ea. or 5 for $38
LARGE NIGHT VIEWERS
One of a kind! A very large complete viewer for
long range observation. Based on a 3-stage fibre
optically coupled 40mm first generation image
intensifier, with a low light 200mm objective mirror
lens. Designed for tripod mounting. Probably the
highest gain-resolution night viewer ever made.
ONE ONLY at an incredible price of:
$3990
BINOCULAR EHT POWER SUPPLY
This low current EHT power supply was originally
used to power the IR binoculars advertised elsewhere in this listing. It is powered by a single 1.5V
“C” cell and produces a negative voltage output
of approximately 12kV. Can be used for powering
prefocussed IR tubes etc.
$20
IR BINOCULARS
High quality helmet mount, ex-military binocular
viewer. Self-powered by one 1.5V “C” size battery.
Focus adjustable from 1 metre to infinity. Requires
IR illumination. Original carry case provided. Limited
stocks, ON SPECIAL AT:
$500
IR FILTERS
A high quality military grade, deep infrared filter.
Used to filter the IR spectrum from medium-high
powered spotlights. Its glass construction makes
it capable of withstanding high temperatures.
Approx. 130mm diameter and 6mm thick. For use
with IR viewers and IR responsive CCD cameras:
ON SPECIAL
$45
12V OPERATED LASERS WITH KIT
SUPPLY
Save by making your own laser inverter kit. This
combination includes a new HeNe visible red laser
tube and one of our 12V Universal Laser Power
Supply MkIII kits. This inverter is easy to construct
as the transformer is assembled. The supply powers
HeNe tubes with powers of 0.2-15mW.
$130 with 1mW TUBE
$180 with 5mW TUBE
$280 with 10mW TUBE
MAINS OPERATED LASER
Supplied with a new visible red HeNe laser tube with
its matching encapsulated (240V) supply.
$179 with 1mW TUBE
$240 with 5mW TUBE
$390 with 10mW TUBE
GREEN LASER HEADS
We have a limited quantity of some brand new
2mW+ laser heads that produce a brillant green
output beam. Because of the relative response of the
human eye, these appear about as bright as 5-8mW
red helium neon tubes. Approximately 500mm long
by 40mm diameter, with very low divergence. Priced
at a small fraction of their real value
$599
A 12V universal laser inverter kit is provided for
free with each head.
ARGON HEADS
These low-voltage air-cooled Argon lon Laser Heads
are priced according to their hours of operation.
They produce a bright BLUE BEAM (488nm) and
a power output in the 10-100mW range. Depends
on the tube current. The head includes power meter
circuitry, and starting circuitry. We provide a simple
circuit for the supply and can provide some of the
major components for this supply. Limited supplies
at a fraction of their real cost.
$450-$800
ARGON OPTIC SETS
If you intend to make an Argon laser tube, the
most expensive parts you will need are the two
mirrors contained in this ARGON LASER OPTIC
SET. Includes one high reflector and one output
coupler at a fraction of their real value. LIMITED
SUPPLY
$200 for the two Argon LASER mirrors.
LASER POINTER
Improve and enhance all your presentations. Not
a kit but a complete commercial 5mW/670nm pen
sized pointer at ONLY:
$149
LARGE LENSES
Two pairs of these new precision ground AR coated
lenses were originally used to make up one large
symmetrical lens for use in IBM equipment. Made
in Japan by TOMINON. The larger lens has a
diameter of 80mm and weighs 0.5kg. Experimenters
delight at only:
$15 for the pair.
EHT GENERATOR KIT
A low cost EHT generator kit for experimenting
with HT-EHT voltages: DANGER – HIGH VOLTAGE! The kit also doubles as a very inexpensive
power supply for laser tubes: See EL-CHEAPO
LASER. Powered from a 12V DC supply, the EHT
generator delivers a pulsed DC output with peak
output voltage of approximately 11kV. By adding
a capacitor (.001uF/15kV $4), the kit will deliver
an 11kV DC output. By using two of the lower
voltage taps available on the transformer, it is
possible to obtain other voltages: 400V and 1300V
by simply adding a suitable diode and a capacitor:
200mA - 3kV diode and 0.01uF 5kV capacitor: $3
extra for the pair.
Possible uses include EHT experiments, replacement supplies in servicing (Old radios/CRO’s),
plasma balls etc. The EHT generator kit now includes
the PCB and is priced at a low:
$23
LED DISPLAYS
National Seminconductor 7-segment common
cathode 12 digit multiplexed LED displays with 12
decimal points. Overall size is 60 x 18mm and pinout
diagram is provided.
2.50 Ea. or 5 for $10
BATTERIES
Brand new industrial grade PANASONIC 12V-6.5AHr
sealed gel batteries at a reduced price.Yes, 6.5 AHr
batteries for use in alarms, solar lighting systems,
etc. Dimensions: 100 x 954 x 65mm. Weight of one
battery is 2.2kG. The SPECIAL price?
$38
PIR DETECTORS
What are the expensive parts in a passive movement dector as per EA May 89? A high quality dual
element PIR sensor, plus a fresnel lens, plus a white
filter. We include these and a copy of PIR movement
detector circuit diagram for:
$9
MASTHEAD AMPLIFIER KIT
Based on an IC with 20dB of gain, a bandwidth of
2GHz and a noise figure of 2.8dB, this amplifier kit
outperforms most other similar ICs and is priced
at a fraction of their cost. The cost of the complete
kit of parts for the masthead amplifier PCB and
components and the power and signal combiner
PCB and components is AN INCREDIBLE:
$18
For more information see a novel and extremely
popular antenna design which employs this amplifier: MIRACLE TV ANTENNA - EA May 1992: Box,
balun, and wire for this antenna: $5 extra
SODIUM VAPOUR LAMPS
Brand new 140W low pressure sodium vapour
lamps. Overall length 520mm, 65mm diameter, GEC
type SO1/H. We supply data for a very similar lamp
(135W). CLEARANCE AT:
lenses: two plastic and one glass. The basis of
a high quality magnifier, or projection system?
Experimenters’ delight!
$30
CRYSTAL OSCILLATOR MODULES
These small TTL Quartz Crystal Oscillators are hermetically sealed. Similar to units used in computers.
Operate from 5V and draw approximately 30mA.
TTL logic level clock output. Available in 4MHz,
4.032MHz, 5.0688MHz, 20MHz, 20.2752MHz,
24.74MHz, 40MHz and 50MHz.
$7 Ea. or 5 for $25
FLUORESCENT BACKLIGHT
These are new units supplied in their original
packing. They were an option for backlighting Citizen
LCD colour TVs. The screen glows a brilliant white
colour when the unit is powered by a 6V battery.
Draws approximately 50mA. The screen and the
inverter PCB can be separated. Effective screen
size is 38 x 50mm.
$12
MAINS FILTER BARGAIN
For two displays - one yellow green and one
silver grey.
SOME DIFFERENT COMPONENTS
1000pF/15kV disc ceramic capacitors ..............$5
20kV PIV - 5mA Av/1A Pk fast diodes .........$1.50
3kV PIV - 300mA / 30A Pk fast diodes ........... 60c
0.01uF /5kV disc ceramic capacitors ...........$1.80
680pF / 3kV disc ceramic capacitors .............. 30c
Who said that power MOSFETS are expensive??
MTP3055 N-channel MOSFETS as used in many
SC projects ............................$2 Ea. or 10 for $15
MTP2955 P-channel MOSFETS (complementary
to MTP3055) ..........................$2 Ea. or 10 for $15
BUZ11 N-channel MOSFETS $3 Ea. or 10 for $25
Brief DATA and application sheet for above MOSFETS free with any of their purchases (ask)
Flexible DECIMAL KEYPADS with PCB connectors
to suit ...........................................................$1.50
1-inch CRO TUBES with basic X-Y monitor circuit
CLEARANCE <at>..............................................$20
Schottky Barrier diodes 30V PIV - 1A/25A Pk. 45c
100 LED BARGRAPH DISPLAY
Note that we also have some IEC extension leads
that are two metres long at $4 Ea.
Yes 100 LEDs plus IC control circuitry, all surface
mounted on a long strip of PCB. SIMPLE - a 4-bit
binary code selects which one out of the 10 LED
groups will be on, whilst another 4-bit binary code
selects which one of each group of 10 LEDs will
be ON. Latching inputs are also provided. We
include a circuit and a connecting diagram. VERY
LIMITED QUANTITY
WEATHER TRANSMITTERS
FM TRANSMITTER KIT - MKll
A complete mains filter employing two inductors
and three capacitors fitted in a shielded metal IEC
socket. We include a 40 joule varistor with each filter.
$5
These brand new units were originally intended
to monitor weather conditions at high altitudes:
attached to balloons. Contain a transmitter (12GHz?) humidity sensor, temperature sensor,
barometric altitude sensor, and a 24V battery which
is activated by submersing in water. The precision
all mechanical altitude sensor appears similar
to a barometer and has a mechanical encoder
and is supplied with calibration chart. Great for
experimentation.
$16 Ea.
SOLAR CHARGER
Use it to charge and or maintain batteries on BOATS,
for solar LIGHTING, solar powered ELECTRIC
FENCES etc. Make your own 12V 4 Watt solar
panel. We provide four 6V 1-Watt solar panels with
terminating clips, and a PCB and components
kit for a 12V battery charging regulator and a
three LED charging indicator: see March 93 SC.
Incredible value!
$42
6.5Ahr. PANASONIC gel Battery $35, ELECTRIC
FENCE PCB and all onboard components kit $40.
See SC April 93.
$7Ea.
This low cost FM transmitter features pre-emphasis, high audio sensitivity as it can easily pick
up normal conversation in a large room, a range
of well over 100 metres, etc. It also has excellent
frequency stability. The resultant frequency shift
due to waving the antenna away and close to a
human body and/or changing the supply voltage
by +/-1V at 9V will not produce more than 30kHz
deviation at 100MHz! That represents a frequency
deviation of less than 0.03%, which simply means
that the frequency stays within the tuned position
on the receiver.
Specifications: tuning range: 88-101MHz, supply
voltage 6-12V, current consumption <at>9V 3.5mA,
pre-emphasis 50µs or 75µs, frequency response
40Hz to greater than 15kHz, S/N ratio greater than
60dB, sensitivity for full deviation 20mV, frequency
stability (see notes) 0.03%, PCB dimensions
1-inch x 1.7inch.
Construction is easy and no coil winding is necessary. The coil is preassembled in a shielded metal
can. The double sided, solder masked and screened
PCB also makes for easy construction. The kit
includes a PCB and all the on-board components,
an electret microphone, and a 9V battery clip:
$11 Ea. or 3 for $30
LARGE LCD DISPLAY MODULE - HITACHI
These are Hitachi LM215XB, 400 x 128 dot displays.
Some are silver grey and some are yellow green
reflective types. These were removed from unused
laptop computers. We sold out of similar displays that
were brand new at $39 each but are offering these
units at about half price. VERY LIMITED STOCK.
$40
OATLEY ELECTRONICS
$15 Ea.
PO Box 89, Oatley, NSW 2223
STEPPER MOTORS
Phone (02) 579 4985. Fax (02) 570 7910
$12
MAJOR CARDS ACCEPTED WITH
PHONE & FAX ORDERS
These are brand new units. Main body has a diameter of 58mm and a height of 25mm. Will operate
from 5V, has 7.5deg. steps, coil resistance of 6.6
ohms, and it is a 2-phase type. Six wires. ONLY:
PROJECTION LENS
Brand new large precison projection lens which
was originally intended for big screen TV projection systems. Will project images at close proximity
onto walls and screens and it has adjustable
focussing. Main body has a diameter of 117mm
and is 107mm long. The whole assembly can
be easily unscrewed to obtain three very large
P & P FOR MOST MIXED ORDERS
AUSTRALIA: $6; NZ (Air Mail): $10
July 1993 7
and further back. The 200-inch (5m)
Hale telescope on Mount Palomar in
southern California would not have
been possible without the development of Pyrex, a low expansion glass
which allowed the 14.5-tonne mirror
to reach thermal equilibrium in time
for the astronomers to still have some
dark hours in which to do their work!
The development of air-conditioning and efficient insulating materials
also helped by keeping the inside of
the dome and hence the mirror at a
constant average night-time temperature; ie, cold. Nevertheless, Mount
Palomar seems to be about the largest
size telescope that can be made using
conventional mirrors and equatorial
mountings.
Continuing the development of new
techniques, the 6-metre BTA (Bolshoi
Teleskop Azimutal’ny = Large Alta
zimuth Telescope) on Mount Pastuk
hov in southern Russia was the first
large telescope to use an altazimuth
mount instead of an equatorial, since
the equatorial would have been too
massive to control accurately, and too
costly to build.
But the advent of the altazimuth
mount had to await computers with
sufficient power to control the continually changing position of the
telescope, since the calculations to
move each axis are far more complex
than the requirements of an equatorial
mount, where (more or less) the drive
has only to be able to rotate the polar
axis at the sidereal rate.
Altazimuth telescopes have the
additional complexity of field rotation
8 Silicon Chip
during ob
serva
tion, a problem not
encountered with equatorial mounts.
Further computing and mechanical
complexity is involved in resolving
this problem.
The type of glass used in a tele
scope mirror has a great bearing on
the ultimate size that can be produced.
Ordinary borosilicate glass is easy to
cast in large sizes and to stress relieve
after casting, but thermal expansion is
so great that it is unusable in this role.
The development of Pyrex, in reducing thermal expansion to tolerable
limits, enabled much larger mirrors
to be contemplated, but casting an
homogenous blank was far more difficult, and it had a tendency to crack
when being stress-relieved, a process
that often took months or even years
of slow cooling. Fused quartz has been
used successfully but the extreme
difficulty of making large blanks has
limited its use on very large telescopes,
as has the development of new and
better materials.
As each new glass was developed,
the rewards in temperature stability
were greater, but so were the problems of manufacture. Cervit and its
Soviet counterpart SITAL (used in the
replacement mirror for the 6-metre
telescope) were the first successful
attempts to make a complex ceramic-glass mixture, where the coefficient
of expansion of the ceramic almost
exactly countered the opposite coefficient of expansion of the glass.
This was taken a step further with
the development of Zerodur by Schott
of Mainz, Germany. After initial cast-
ing, careful control of the subsequent
stabilising/stress-relieving thermal
cycle results in a glass in which half
of the mass is cryptocrystalline and
half is a supercooled liquid – the socalled “ceramization” process. Again,
the coefficients of expansion of the
two phases are equal but opposite and
closely cancel each other out.
The worst example of thermal
problems in a large telescope came
with the original 42-tonne pyrex-like
primary of the BTA, where a change
of no more than 20°C per day in glass
temperature could be tolerated and
still maintain a useable figure during
night-time observing runs.
The next development was that of
thin-mirror telescopes. Usually, the
thickness:diameter ratio of the glass
blank is between 1:6 to 1:8. As mentioned before, these larger mirrors become inordinately heavy and need to
be supported by inordinately massive
mounts, and the problem of pointing
finesse and controllability as well as
thermal equilibrium considerations
again dictate limits.
Thus was born experimentation
and success
ful implementation of
thin-mirror technology, with thickness:diameter ratios of 1:10 to 1:25.
These were made possible by the rigidity of the newly developed glasses,
and by casting the blanks so that they
tapered in thickness from the centre
out, as well as having anti-flexure webs
incorporated on the rear of the mirror.
This went a great way to reducing the
problems associated with weight, flexure and thermal equilibrium.
ORDER FORM
BACK ISSUES
MONTH
YEAR
MONTH
YEAR
PR ICE EACH (includes p&p)
Australi a $A7.00; NZ $A8.00 (airmail ); Elsewhere $A10
(airmail ). Buy 10 or more and get a 10% discount.
Note: Nov 87-Aug 88; Oct 88-Mar 89; June 89; Aug 89;
Dec 89; May 90; Aug 91; Feb 92; July 92; Sept 92; NovDec 92; & March 98 are sol d out. All other issues are
currently i n stock.
TOTAL
$A
B INDERS
Pl ease send me _______ SILICON CHIP bi nder(s) at
$A12.95 + $5.00 p&p each (Australi a only). N ot avail abl e
elsewhere. Buy five and get them postage free.
$A
SUBSCRIPTIONS
❏ New subscription – month to start___________________________
❏ Renewal – Sub. No._______________ ❏ Gift subscription ☞
RATES (please tick one)
Australia
Australia with binder(s)*
NZ & PNG (airmail)
Overseas surface mail
2 years (24 issues) 1 year (12 issues)
❏ $A84
❏ $A42
❏ $A105
❏ $A53
❏ $A130
❏ $A65
❏ $A130
❏ $A65
❏ $A240
Overseas airmail
❏ $A120
*1 binder with 1-year subscription; 2 binders with 2-year subscription
GIFT SUBSCRIPTION DETAILS
Month to start__________________
Message_____________________
_____________________________
_____________________________
Gift for:
Name_________________________
(PLEASE PRINT)
YOUR DETAILS
Your Name_________________________________________________
(PLEASE PRINT)
Address___________________________________________________
Address______________________
_____________________________
State__________Postcode_______
______________________________________Postcode___________
Daytime Phone No.____________________Total Price $A __________
❏ Cheque/Money Order
❏ Bankcard ❏ Visa Card ❏ Master Card
9am-5pm Mon-Fri.
Please have your credit card
details ready
10 Silicon Chip
______________________________
Card expiry date________/________
Card No.
Phone (02) 9979 5644
Signature
OR
Fax (02) 9979 6503
Fax the coupon with your
credit card details
24 hours 7 days a week
Mail coupon to:
OR
Reply Paid 25
Silicon Chip Publications
PO Box 139, Collaroy 2097
No postage stamp required in Australia
As each of the above problems of
large mirror making were more or
less, successfully solved, even larger
mirrors became feasible. But there
remained one difficulty that couldn’t
be reduced easily – that of the actual
figuring and final polishing of the
reflecting surface itself. It is generally
agreed amongst optical engineers that
doubling the diameter of a mirror
makes it 10 times more difficult more
difficult to grind.
The amount of material to be removed is significantly greater, and the
final zonal corrections are fraught with
time-consuming difficulty. If one zone
is high, it only has to be polished down
to specification, but if it is low, the
entire surface has to be polished down
to accommodate the low spot. Even
though we are speaking of microns,
the work involved in polishing down
a large mirror is massive. And always
bearing in mind that not only does the
final figure have to be good, but the
focal point cannot be changed by any
corrections or re-figuring, as by this
abolise or hyperbolise the surface by
deepening the centre with a sub-diameter polishing lap.
The first new technique is a computer controlled polishing engine, usually
combined with a laser profilometer
feeding back to the controller. It has
the advantage of good accuracy and
is much quicker and less labour intensive than manual polishing. Since
large mirrors are so seldom made, the
computer polisher is usually made as
a one-off special for that particular
mirror and this adds substantially to
the cost, speed of execution notwith
standing.
The second new technique is known
as spin-casting. Glass is melted in an
electrically heated mould and held for
a time to soak so as to remove as many
bubbles and other imperfections and
inclusions as possible, and then spun
whilst cooling to produce the required
paraboloidal shape. The mould also
incorporates a honeycomb base which
creates a lightweight blank. The resulting curved blank dramatically reduces
All this had to come together at the top of a
windswept mountain where the air is so thin
that the engineers & construction workers
had to contend with dizziness, headaches,
forgetfulness & dehydration.
time the structural engineering side
would be well on the way to designing
and building the mounting, which by
now cannot be changed.
There is also a trend to design large
telescopes with very fast optics, often
less than f/2. Firstly, this gives the
observer a much brighter image to
work with, albeit at a reduced image
scale. Also, the supporting structure
can be much lighter because of the
shorter tube involved and significant
savings can be made in the design and
construction of the dome.
Two techniques are successfully
used today to partially overcome the
difficulty of grinding and polishing
mirrors to the required shape. Virtually all telescope mirrors have a para
boloidal or hyperboloidal cross-section and the traditional technique is
to first grind it to a spherical surface,
and then after testing for the sphere
by traditional optical means, to par-
the amount of material that has to be
removed and hence the time to attain
the final figure.
Several large astronomical mirrors
in the 6-metre to 8-metre range have
been cast successfully with this method, although at least three (8.2- metre
blanks for the European Southern Observatory’s Very Large Telescope –VLT)
have cracked and have been destroyed
in the annealing stage.
A final technique that had been
discussed theoretically for years is
that of stressed mirror polishing. In
effect, the mirror blank is deliberately
distorted to a predetermined shape
and then polished to a spherical section by conventional methods. After
final polishing, the distorting forces
are removed, and the mirror takes up
(hopefully!) the desired shape.
The greatest proponent of this new
method was Jerry Nelson of the University of California. In the late 1970s
he proposed that large astronomical
mirrors could be produced this way.
He made a further proposal, one that
was to have a great bearing on the
design and building of modern tele
scopes – that large mirrors be made
of multiple segmented smaller mirrors
rather than one large blank.
The idea of segmented mirrors to
avoid the weight problem and the increased complexity that accompanies
figuring large single mirrors is not new,
having been discussed by the third Earl
of Ross in the mid 1800s. In the late
1940s, Horn-d’Aturo in Italy actually
made a 61 hexagonal-segment mirror.
This formed a 1.8-metre f/6 telescope
that gave good images, although it was
unsteerable.
With the previously discussed years
of telescope design, glass making and
polishing technology, and adequate
computing power, the stage was set for
the development of the most ambitious
optical device ever built, the 9.82-metre W. M. Keck telescope.
The driving force behind the radical new telescope was Jerry Nelson.
He spent a great deal of time convincing the pundits that such a project
was feasible, since nothing on this
scale had ever been tried before. From
the start, the concept and design
were revolutionary. New methods
had to be devised to construct mirror segments, the warping harness,
support struc
t ure, actuators, and
the computer programs that brought
them all together.
The segmented mirror design on
such a large telescope was novel, and
there was no previous experience
at this scale to draw on. The mount
would have to be rigid enough to keep
the segments in exquisite alignment
but light enough to gain from the benefit of such a design. The electronics to
sense and correct misalignment had to
be developed from scratch. Even the
grinding and polishing of the mirror
segments themselves were to use new
and untried techniques.
In all facets, innovative thinking and
methods had to be employed. And all
this had to come together at the top
of a windswept mountain where the
air is so thin that the engineers and
construction workers had to contend
with dizziness, forget
fulness, headaches and dehydration, while solving
the engineering problems that would
be inevitable with such a massive
SC
undertaking.
July 1993 11
|