This is only a preview of the June 2020 issue of Silicon Chip. You can view 41 of the 112 pages in the full issue, including the advertisments. For full access, purchase the issue for $10.00 or subscribe for access to the latest issues. Items relevant to "Our new RCL Subsitution Box has touchscreen control":
Items relevant to "Vintage Workbench":
Articles in this series:
Items relevant to "Tough Roadies’ Test Oscillator":
Items relevant to "H-Field AM Radio Receiver Transanalyser, Part 2":
Articles in this series:
Purchase a printed copy of this issue for $10.00. |
Last month we described
how this all-in-one AM
radio test and alignment
device works and gave
the PCB assembly
instructions. Now we
have the details of how
to wire it up, test it,
calibrate it and finish
the assembly by
mounting it in a
diecast case.
The
H-field
Transanalyser
Part 2 –
by Dr Hugo Holden
I
f you’re building the Transanalyser and have been following along,
you should have a fully assembled
PCB. But it is not quite ready to be
powered up yet.
So let’s get onto wiring up the remaining components that are not
mounted on the PCB.
Chassis wiring
You can do the chassis wiring, plug
everything together and test the unit
before fitting it into its case. It may not
perform brilliantly due to the lack of
shielding, but if there is something
wrong, it will be much easier to fix it
at this stage.
But before you can test it, you need
to wire up the DC socket, three chassis-mounting pots, the three input
and output sockets and the LED frequency meter.
As the wiring is somewhat complicated, in addition to the following de84
Silicon Chip
scription, we have produced a wiring
diagram (see Fig.5).
This includes approximate lengths
for each cable run, but note that
you may need to make some adjustments depending on the exact location you’ve mounted the parts in your
chassis.
Also note that the terminal arrangements for VR4 & VR5 may be different depending on which exact parts
you’ve purchased.
Start by cutting a 150mm length of
light-duty figure-8 cable and solder it
to the two live pins of the DC socket.
These sockets usually have three
pins, one of which is open-circuit
when a plug is inserted.
If you aren’t sure which is which,
plug in the plugpack, power it up
and probe the pins with a DMM set to
measure DC volts until you get a sensible reading. If the reading is positive, the red probe is on the + contact,
Australia’s electronics magazine
whereas if it’s negative, the black probe
is on the + contact.
Once you’ve soldered the wire at
that end, crimp and/or solder the
other end to a pair of polarised plug
pins and insert these into a two-way
plastic shell.
When plugged into the DC input
on the board, the wire from the + side
of the DC socket must go to the side
marked + on the PCB.
Next, cut three lengths of shielded wire: 120mm long for METER IN
(CON1), 150mm long for 1kHz OUT
(CON6) and 220mm long for RF OUT
(CON7).
Solder these to the appropriate
plugs, ie, BNC for RF OUT and either
RCA or BNC (depending on your preference) for the other two. The shield
braids go to the outer shields of the
connectors.
Attach two-way header plugs to the
other ends of these cables in a similar
siliconchip.com.au
manner as you did for the DC input.
In each case, the inner conductor goes
to the side that matches the + symbol
on the PCB when plugged in, with the
shield braid to the other side.
Make sure none of the shield braid
wires are floating around so that they
might short to something; if they are,
cut them off.
That just leaves the wiring for the
three pots. You need a two-core (three
conductor) shielded cable for the 1kHz
output adjustment potentiometer; the
type often used for stereo audio is fine.
Cut a 120mm length and solder the
shield braid to the anti-clockwise end
of the 5kΩ potentiometer, VR6. The inner two conductors each go to one of
the two other pins.
Crimp and/or solder pins to the
three conductors at the other end,
and insert them into the three-way
plug shell.
Ensure that the wire going to the
clockwise end of the potentiometer (viewed from the front of the pot)
goes to the side marked with a + on
header CON5. The shield braid goes
to the opposite end of the plug, with
the third wire (from the pot wiper) to
the middle pin.
Solder wire off-cuts from the central
wiper connection to the anti-clockwise end terminal on each of the two
remaining pots, so that they become
variable resistors which decrease in
resistance when turned clockwise.
Then cut an 80mm length of figure-8
cable, and solder one end to a pair of
Repeated from last month’s
issue, this is what your
completed PCB should look
like. We used brass strips
for shielding; strips of
tinplate should work but
will rust over time.
pins which are then
inserted into a twoway polarised plug. It
doesn’t matter which
pin goes where.
Split the wires
apart at the opposite end and solder
them to the wiper
terminals of VR4
and VR5. Then
run a short length of
medium-duty hookup wire between the clockwise terminals of VR4
and VR5.
The only part left to wire up is the
LED frequency meter. Cut a 50mm
length of shielded cable and a 100mm
length of light-duty figure-8 cable.
Crimp and/or solder these to pairs of
pins and insert them into two-way
plugs, either way around.
The shielded cable will go to the
signal input on the back of the frequency meter, and the figure-8 cable
to the power input.
These cables then meet at a single
three-way plug to go to CON4 on the
main PCB. The positive wire for the
figure-8 power cable goes to the end
marked + on the PCB, while the sig-
Scope1: this shows the RF output signal from CON7 when
the 1kHz signal going into the modulator is disabled,
resulting in a pure carrier wave. The frequency setting is
around 1800kHz (ie, at the upper end of the adjustment
range) and you can see that the sinewave is quite pure.
siliconchip.com.au
nal input goes to the middle pin. Both
ground wires must be connected to the
third pin, at the opposite end from the
+ symbol.
Testing and calibration
If you’ve used IC sockets, make sure
all the ICs are plugged in now, with
the correct orientation and in the right
locations. Now is also a good time to
pop the plastic cover off the analog
meter and replace the 0-1mA scale inside with a 0-1mV (or similar) scale.
Temporarily attach the analog meter to the front of the PCB by removing
Scope2: the same signal as in Scope1 but the 1kHz
signal has been re-enabled, so it is now 30% amplitude
modulated. If the output of your unit does not look like
this, adjust trimpot VR3 to get the correct modulation level.
Australia’s electronics magazine
June 2020 85
Next, connect a sinewave of known
amplitude to the meter input, set S1
to select the correct range (fully anticlockwise = 10V, one step clockwise =
1V etc) and then adjust VR1 to get the
correct reading on the analog meter.
Final assembly
Only four holes are required on the rear
“panel” (which happens to be the base of
the diecast case). Position is not particularly
critical but the locations shown make sense.
the nuts from its two rear screw shafts,
feeding these through the holes on the
PCB marked “To meter”, “CON2” and
attaching the screws to these pads using a nut on either side (you need nuts
just behind the meter to space it off so
that it clears the solder joints under it).
Plug all these cables into the appropriate headers on the main PCB (see
labels and the text above for an idea
of which goes where), prop it up in
a convenient location on a non-conducting surface and make sure none
of the floating components and wires
are shorting together.
Since you were careful to connect
the plug wires correctly earlier, once
you’ve made sure the right plugs go to
the right headers on the board, all the
connections should be right.
That just leaves the two plugs which
go to the frequency meter. As the headers on that board are not polarised,
they can go either way around. So
check the labelling on the back of the
frequency meter carefully and ensure
that both plugs go into the right sockets
(the shielded cable carries the signal)
and that they have the right orientation, with the shield braid and ground
wire connecting to ground.
Once that’s sorted out, set rotary
switch S1 on the board fully anticlockwise and S2 (at top) fully clockwise. Adjust VC1 and VR1-VR3 to
86
Silicon Chip
their halfway points and flip toggle
switch S3 up.
Apply 12V power to the floating DC
socket; nothing should happen since
the power switch is off. Flip S3 and
check that the frequency meter lights
up. Adjusting floating potentiometers
VR4 and VR5 should change the frequency reading.
Rotate VR4 and VR5 fully anti-clockwise and adjust VC1 to get a reading close to 205kHz on the frequency
meter display. Now rotate both fully
clockwise and check that the reading
goes up to at least 1.8MHz.
For proper calibration, you need
an oscilloscope or spectrum analyser. Connect this to the RF output on
your instrument, set its input impedance to 75Ω (or use a 75Ω terminator)
and adjust VR2 for a maximum carrier amplitude of 50mV RMS (141mV
peak-to-peak).
Adjust VR3 to get a modulation
depth of about 30%, which means
a carrier amplitude at the troughs of
35mV RMS (100mV peak-to-peak).
Scope2 shows what the unit’s output should look like with 30% modulation, while Scope1 shows the carrier with the modulator disabled (eg,
with Q1’s base shorted to its emitter).
Both grabs were taken with the loop
connected, so the output is correctly
loaded to give a 50mV RMS signal.
Australia’s electronics magazine
If you were able to complete the
above calibration, then it seems that
everything is working correctly and
you can start preparing the case. Fig.6
shows the holes that need to be drilled
and cut. You may need to enlarge the
hole “A” at the far right of the case,
depending on whether you’re using
a bezel for the LED and how big it is.
To make the rectangular cut-out for
the frequency meter, drill a series of
small holes inside the perimeter, join
them up with a file, knock out the
piece inside and then file the edges
to shape. Don’t worry about getting
it perfect since we’ll be fitting a bezel
over the top later, but the meter needs
to fit into the hole, and you don’t want
any huge chunks missing from around
the edges.
You can make the large round hole
for the analog meter in a similar manner, but it will be easier if you use a
44mm hole saw, which cost around $8
at most hardware stores. As the hole
size is specified as 44.5mm, if you
find your meter won’t fit through, file
around the edges until it does.
You also need to drill four holes in
the rear of the case, close to the bottom
edge. We haven’t produced a drilling
template as their exact locations are
not critical.
Just make sure to drill them along
a line parallel to the edge of the case,
so it looks neat, and space the three
on the left side apart evenly. Try to get
the positions reasonably close to ours,
as the cable lengths given earlier are
based on those locations.
When finished, deburr all the holes.
You can then consider painting and labelling the case. While not necessary,
it gives a more professional-looking
result.
After drilling and cutting my box, I
first treated it with Bondrite, which is
an Alodine-like etching agent. I then
painted it with VHT spray paint from
a can, and baked at 93°C in a home
oven for an hour. You don’t need to
go to quite that much trouble; a few
light coats from a can of decent spray
paint suited to aluminium should give
an acceptable result.
siliconchip.com.au
Using the Transanalyser with valve radios
ing transformer so that the chassis can be
Earthed for making measurements and injecting signals.
Like most professional-grade RF generators, the Transanalyser’s RF OUT is DCcoupled and has a low impedance (75).
So in many cases, you will need to insert
a high-voltage series capacitor (say 10nF)
+
+
3.9k
5819
18k
1 F
CON6
1kHz out
IC3
TL072
2.2k
CON5
To pot
E
VC1
Q1
MOD1
ITB0505S
10F
C
L2 +
VR6
4
330 H
Q1:2N2222
6
~ 120mm
~ 150mm
~ 120mm
1
2
10F
+
+
B
~ 150mm
100nF
100nF
15 F
2.2k
5.6k
100nF
IC2
TL072
2.2k
510
220 F
2.2k
3 100
BAT46
IC1
TL072
680pF
D1
4148
4148
D2
430k
3x 10nF
10F
2
12pF
D3
CON2
VR3
100nF 500
+
180k
CON1Meter in
18k
1
100k
100nF
4
D4
BAT46
L1 330 H
–
+
+
10nF
1.8k
1.8k
180nF
100nF
+
180k
10F
+
+
12
5
A
VR5
+
12V DC in
100nF
+
6
11
CON8
To meter VR1 500
7
10
1 F
+
9
10 F
100nF
~ 50mm
CONNECTS
TO PIN 3
(TOWARDS
FRONT)
+
06102201 RevA
H-field Transanalyser
Dr. Hugo Holden
8
100nF
REG1
7805
1N5819
+
10 F +
+
To counter CON4
+
1k
MAX038
10k
1 F
220 F
(LED1)
390pF
CCW
~ 80mm
CON3
Freq adjust
2k
CW
12k
27pF
IC4
510
1 F
100nF
300
100nF
D5
100nF
100nF
100nF
1k
100
5.1k
3k
78L09
100k
5.6k
10
2k
7.5k
27k
5.1k
75
75
VR2
500
REG2
IC5 MC1496
1k
5
VR4
100nF
5.1k
100nF
6
3.9k
4
1.8k
3.9k
GND
+
1.8k
100nF
1.3k
3.9k
100nF
100
IC6
AD8056
1k
7
100nF
1.8k
1 F
300
1.3k
75
110
3.9k
8
10 F
100nF
RF
INPUT
~ 60mm
3.9k
2k
110
3.9k
110
75
75
1.8k
75
1.8k
3.9k
150
110
3.9k
9
75
CON7
3
110
1.8k
75
110
A
110
3.9k
75
1.8k
2
10
+
110
3.9k
1
75
75
150
RF out
3.6k
11
+
A
+
12
3.6k
to couple the signal into various points
in a valve circuit. You may also need to
include a series resistor to increase its
effective output impedance to suit the
circuitry being tested.
For example, add a 220series resistor
to couple the signal into a circuit expecing
a ~300source impedance.
PLJ-6LED-AS FREQUENCY COUNTER MODULE (REAR VIEW)
Fig.5: use this diagram as a guide when you’re wiring
up the unit. The wire lengths are based on our
–
prototype; measure yours to verify they’re right
POWER
before cutting (remember to leave extra for the
+
stripped sections at each end and also some
slack for case assembly/disassembly). The
panel meter is not shown here. It mounts
on the opposite side of the PCB to the two
large pads either side of VR1, with M4 nuts
~ 120mm
on both sides of the board in each case.
100nF
As noted in the text, the Transanalyser
is intended mainly for use with transistor
AM radios. But the 1kHz OUT and RF OUT
terminals are provided so that it can also
be used with valve-based gear.
If you are making any sort of direct connection to a valve radio with a
hot chassis, you need to use an isolat-
~ 220mm
REAR OF CASE
CON1
siliconchip.com.au
CON6
CON7
Australia’s electronics magazine
CON8
June 2020 87
37
37
C
C
A
25
B
18.5
A
27.5
A
A
42.5
WINDOW
20 x 76
42.25
18.5
50
18.5
A
A
38.5
18.5
27
CL
44.5
DIAMETER
24
42.25
A
A
A
18.5
29
4
75
A
A
C
37
37
C
C
Fig.6: most of the
holes that need to be
made in the case are
in the lid. The large
rectangular cut-out
for the frequency
meter can be made
by drilling a series of
small holes inside the
outline, filing them
together until the
middle section falls
out, then filing the
edges out to match
the outline. If you
don’t have a suitable
hole saw, the 44.5mm
diameter circular hole
can also be made this
way. Note that this
diagram is reproduced
slightly less than same
size – case size is
actually 222 x 146mm.
HOLES A: 3.0mm DIAMETER
ALL DIMENSIONS ARE IN MILLIMETRES
HOLES B: 6.0mm DIAMETER
HOLES C: 9.0mm DIAMETER
CL
I made the labels with a Brother
tape label machine, with white text
on transparent tape. Use whatever labelling method you prefer.
Once the labels are attached, mount
the frequency meter by feeding in four
88
Silicon Chip
machine screws through the bezel,
then the holes around the rectangular cut-out, and screw them into the
spacers which come pre-fitted to the
counter module. Make sure it’s the
right way up, with the display deciAustralia’s electronics magazine
mal points towards the bottom.
Next, put the LED bezel into its hole
and attach the PCB to the inside of the
case using the two rotary switch nuts
on the right-hand side and a tapped
spacer and two machine screws
siliconchip.com.au
This photo shows how the PCB “hangs” from the front panel, supported by standoffs and the controls. Note that this is a
photo of an early prototype board – the final PCB will look somewhat different.
through the PCB mounting hole and
corresponding front panel hole at left.
We’ve specified a countersunk machine screw for the PCB mounting
spacer through the front panel so that
it sits flush, but you could use a panhead type if you don’t want to countersink the hole.
Make sure the LED goes into its bezel
as you bring the PCB up to the inside
face of the case; note that you could
get away without a bezel if you make
the hole the same size as the LED lens.
The Transanalyser’s case was mounted on 12mm thick tilted plastic feet
attached with machine screws, so the
front face adopts a 9° backwards tilt,
to make it easier to view on the bench.
If installing feet, do so now.
Then fit all the chassis-mounting
components and wire them up to the
main board, as you did before for testing. That includes the frequency meter.
Leave the rear-panel components until last, as once you plug them in, access to the PCB will be limited. Then
join the two halves of the case together
using the supplied screws. Attach all
the knobs to the various shafts and the
main unit is finished.
The final step is to make up the cable that will be used to deliver the signal to the radio’s antenna. You can see
my arrangement in the photo on p91.
I soldered the bare ends of the coax to
a small piece of PCB material and attached two tiny thumb nut terminals.
These allow the thin wire loop to be
connected and disconnected as needed.
You will need to come up with a
similar arrangement, although there
are different ways you could achieve
it. For example, the wire only needs to
be disconnected at one end, and you
could use a spring clip or some other
wire connection device.
The loop should be made from thin
wire-wrap wire or similar, so it can be
threaded through a narrow space. This
siliconchip.com.au
may be necessary where ferrite rods
are mounted close to the radio case.
Wire wrap wire works very well as it
is delicate and easy to thread around
a rod coil, easy to twist and doesn’t
put excessive force on the sometimes
delicate ferrite rod coil wires nearby.
Using it
Disconnect the small loop from the
end of the test lead and thread it once
around the radio’s ferrite rod antenna.
The flying leads with alligator clips
that lead to the Meter input circuit are
connected across the radio’s volume
control outer terminals.
The loop has a very low reactance
over the operating frequency range and
acts like a dead short until the loop is
placed around the ferrite rod. The resonant frequency of the tuned circuit on
the rod then matches the applied frequency, and at that point, the loop’s
impedance increases.
The signal level at the volume control connection (detector output) is
measured on the millivoltmeter in the
Transanalyser. Why this is the preferred place to measure the radio’s response and not at the speaker output
is explained later.
Some calibration protocols and test
instruments rely on monitoring the
power level at the radio’s speaker,
with the RF input sensitivity quoted
for say 50mW at the speaker. However, because there is a wide variation of
speaker impedances, this sort of testing
is fraught with difficulties and pitfalls.
Also, consider that depending on
the volume control setting, the output
stage could be driven into clipping, giving a false reading across the speaker.
So I think it is better to test and analyse a transistor radio by monitoring
the RMS voltage from its detector (or
top leg of the volume control), rather
than by a connection to the speaker.
The audio amplification stage of
Australia’s electronics magazine
the radio can be checked separately
by using the variable level 1kHz test
tone provided by the Transanalyser.
It is unlikely that the audio amplifier
in small transistor radios would have
to be checked at different frequencies,
so the fixed 1kHz test tone should be
adequate.
The transformers and speaker largely
determine the frequency response in
most vintage transistor radios, along
with the capacitors in the output stage
on later transistor radios. Any such
electrolytic capacitors can be checked
for ESR, leakage and capacitance easily, to verify that they are not having
any adverse effect on the output frequency response due to ageing.
For radios with transformer-less audio amplifier designs (like the Hacker
Sovereign and others), the only way to
be 100% sure about the audio amplifier functionality is to do a full audio
frequency sweep; however, a good listening test manipulating the bass and
treble controls would show any significant fault.
The Transanalyser could be modified for its frequency synthesizer IC
to produce an audio sweep, but in the
interests of simplicity, I thought that
to be unnecessary.
IF alignment
For IF alignment, you just need to set
the Transanalyser to the correct intermediate frequency and feed the signal
in via the loop as usual. The modulated IF signal will easily break through
the mixer to the IF stages (even with
the local oscillator running). This is
preferable to injecting a 455kHz signal into the mixer output, as this alters the tuning.
Many transistor radios have a combined mixer-oscillator, so it is not possible to deactivate the oscillator without altering the operating conditions
of the IF amplifier. In cases where the
June 2020 89
Similarly, the early PCB from the opposite side.
Very clear here are the brass shields on the top of the board.
radio has a separate oscillator transistor, it can be unplugged if it has a socket, or its base and emitter temporarily
shorted out to deactivate it. A lower IF
signal level will then be required to be
fed into the antenna.
If the local oscillator is not (or cannot be) deactivated, it is best to have
the radio tuned to the low end of the
band for IF alignment. Regardless, use
the weakest possible IF signal to peak
the IF stages, but keep it above the
noise floor by observing the effect on
the millivoltmeter. Strong signals and
AGC action can alter the IF tuning and
make the tuning peaks more difficult
to observe.
In addition, the test protocol for
aligning IF stages (typically around
455kHz in most transistor radios) involves peaking them on the one centre
frequency. The design of the IF transformers themselves determines the
bandwidth.
This is one reason why a ‘wobulator’
or frequency sweep of the IF amplifiers
in transistor radios has limited utility.
They are not meant to be stagger-tuned
to any specific bandpass characteristic
(unlike the video IF stages in TV sets).
The IF bandpass response can be
easily measured with the Transanalyser. You just adjust the Transanalyser’s
VFO up and down in frequency until
the millivoltmeter reading drops to
about 70% of its peak value, and subtract the two frequency measurements
to determine the -3dB bandwidth.
Aligning transistor radios
Fig.7 shows the adjustments typi-
cally available in AM broadcast band
transistor radios. Rarely, some radios
(such as the NZ-made Pacemaker) have
a three-gang capacitor and an additional radio frequency stage.
There are many variations, so it pays
to check the manufacturer’s alignment
instructions. The information here is a
general guide.
Twin-gang variable capacitor VC1 &
VC2 are often 6-160pF and 5-65pF respectively, or similar value. If the gang
values are the same, a padder capacitor
is used to lower the overall value for
the oscillator. VC1 tunes the antenna
coil and TC1 trims the antenna circuit to set the high-end of the band to
around 1200-1500kHz. A sliding coil
on the ferrite rod is typically used to
set the low end of the band to around
550-600kHz.
VC2 tunes the oscillator coil. A slug
in the oscillator coil is used to set its
lowest frequency to match the dial calibration, while TC2 sets the maximum
oscillator frequency to match the upper dial calibration.
All IF transformer slugs are usually
peaked on the specified centre frequency, typically 455kHz, although 465kHz
is not uncommon. Very old transistor radios such as Regency TR-1 had
262.5kHz IFs. This is why the Transanalyser VFO output goes so low.
The oscillator is arranged to tune
over a set of frequencies which are
above the AM broadcast band by the
intermediate frequency. So if the radio tunes stations from 550-1650kHz
and the IF is 455kHz, the oscillator
tunes over a range of (550+455)kHz to
Fig.7: this shows the typical adjustments that
are available in a transistor AM radio. VC1
& VC2 are the elements of the tuning gang.
These are trimmed by TC1 and TC2 (and
sometimes a moveable coil on the ferrite rod)
to adjust the tuned frequencies at upper and
lower ends of the dial, and to set the tracking.
The IF coils usually have slugs which can be
rotated to peak their response at or near the
intermediate frequency.
90
Silicon Chip
FERRITE ROD
(1650+455)kHz, ie, 1005-2105kHz. The
mixer then generates a difference signal at the same intermediate frequency
for all stations.
Therefore, it is important that the
tracking is correct. This represents the
range of the frequencies tuned by the
antenna coil on the ferrite rod versus
the range of tuned frequencies selected
by the oscillator frequency minus the
IF frequency. The tracking can only
ever be correct at three points; normally near the upper and lower ends
of the band, and right in the middle.
Tracking errors occur on either side,
but they are usually small, so the bandwidth of the IF stages is wide enough
to let signals through that are slightly
off due to these tracking errors.
Generally, the IF is aligned first to
the correct centre frequency. Then a
low-end signal at around 550kHz is
used to adjust the oscillator slug; so
the low end of the dial calibration is
correct. If there is a padder capacitor,
this is used instead of the oscillator
coil slug, radios that use padder capacitors often have no adjustable slug
in the oscillator coil.
Then a high-end signal around
1200-1500kHz (often specified in the
alignment instructions) is used to adjust TC2 to make the dial calibration
correct.
The above process is then repeated
a few times, as one adjustment affects
the other a little. This ensures that the
IF and oscillator are correct and that
the received frequencies are over the
correct range and match the dial calibration as best possible.
LOCAL OSCILLATOR
ANTENNA
COIL
VC1
IF COILS (x3)
OSCILLATOR
SLUG
TC1
TWO GANG VARIABLE CAPACITOR
Australia’s electronics magazine
IF SLUG
VC2
TC2
PADDER IF
PRESENT
SC
2020
siliconchip.com.au
TABLE 1: H-FIELD TRANSANALYSER TEST RESULTS – THREE RADIOS
0dB
–10dB
–20dB
–30dB
–40dB
–50dB
mV OUTPUT
50
20
16
14
13
10
SUBJECTIVE
N0
N0
N0
N0
N1
N3
LEVEL:
HACKER
SOVEREIGN
(2N2084)
–60dB
–70dB
–80dB
Meter fluctuations due to noise
N4
N5
N5
CLIP RATIO = 5
mV OUTPUT
120
160
165
100
70
SUBJECTIVE
N0
N0
N0
N1
N2
Meter fluctuations due to noise
SONY TR-72
N3
N4
N5
N5
CLIP RATIO = 7.5
mV OUTPUT
NORDMENDE
CLIPPER
SUBJECTIVE
300
180
95
80
76
N0
N0
N0
N1
N2
Meter fluctuations due to noise
N3
N4
N5
N5
CLIP RATIO = 7.5
N0: No significant noise heard, just modulation
N1: Audible modulation >> Noise
N2: Audible Noise = Modulation
N3: Audible Noise >> Modulation
N4: Modulation just audible in Noise
N5: Noise heard only
The numerator for the Clip Ratio can
be read right off the Transanalyser’s
voltmeter with its output attenuator
set to 0dB, but the denominator is a
bit more tricky.
You can measure this by connecting the Transanalyser’s 1kHz audio
output between the radio’s volume
control pot wiper and ground, with
the volume control set to mid position
so that the control itself does not load
the applied signal.
You then adjust the 1kHz output
level and measure its amplitude at
the onset of clipping. This is easily
determined without an oscilloscope
by the sound from the speaker. The
‘soft’ sound of the sinewave suddenly
becomes ‘sharp’ with a ‘zinging’ sound
at clipping, due to the high-frequency
harmonics created.
Other notes
Finally, the antenna circuit is
peaked. TC1 is used at the high end.
The low end can only be peaked by
sliding the antenna coil on the ferrite
rod. In many cases, it is completely
sealed with wax and attempting to
move it would damage it, so it is best
to leave it alone and tolerate low end
tracking errors.
Subjective performance tests
Listening to a radio receiver with
a 1kHz modulated RF signal, I have
found it that is very easy to subjectively grade the noise into five categories
without too much ambiguity. I label
them as follows:
• N0 – no significant noise heard,
just the loud and clear demodulated signal
• N1 – modulated signal level is greater than the background noise
• N2 – the modulated signal and noise
levels seem equal
• N3 – noise is dominant, but the modulated signal is still audible
• N4 – the modulated signal is barely
audible in heavy noise
• N5 – only noise is heard.
I tested three radios, and the results
are shown in Table 1. Note how the
Hacker Sovereign (on the AM broadcast band) has relatively low detected
audio voltage levels, but as it has much
more gain in its audio amplifier stages,
the subjective results are better than
the other two radios listed.
This radio had been re-populated
with 2N2084 transistors, as the origisiliconchip.com.au
nals failed from tin whiskers.
Clearly, in the noise department,
the 2N2084 transistors are superior
to those used in the 1956 TR-72 or the
OC44/45 or similar used in the Nordmende Clipper.
The “Clip Ratio” numbers given
are the ratio between the output of
the detector with a strong antenna
signal and the voltage at the wiper
of the volume control pot just on the
edge of clipping.
Another way of looking at this is that
the higher the Clip Ratio, the weaker a
radio station can be and still give you
full volume at the speaker.
This number is a good way of doing
a quick ‘health check’ of a radio even
if you know little about it.
If you get a figure in the range of
4-10, that indicates that the radio’s
front end is more or less healthy and
providing enough signal to the audio
stages for it to be useful even with
weaker (eg, more distant) stations.
In general, when feeding the radio a
test signal from the Transanalyser (or
any source for alignment purposes),
the audio signal (recovered modulation) should be enough to hear clearly above the noise, but not so high
as to induce significant AGC action.
The AGC action minimises the visible
peaks on the output meter, and AGC
also alters the tuning.
For the three radios I tested, a good
level was with the Transanalyser’s
attenuator setting at either -30dB or
-40dB.
It is also possible to use the Transanalyser to determine the signal level
where the radio’s AGC becomes active.
If the radio (or the Transanalyser’s)
tuning frequency is manually adjusted
across the tuned carrier, the millivoltmeter momentarily passes to a higher
value before settling to a lower one,
which is easy to see on the analog meter. This is due to the time constant of
the radio’s AGC filter.
SC
This small PCB, with a 75 terminating
resistor, has screw terminals allowing
the loop to be disconnected and
threaded around the ferrite rod.
An RCA-to-crocodile clip
connector can tap into the
signal for the millvolt
meter or apply signal
from the 1kHz tone generator.
Australia’s electronics magazine
June 2020 91
|