This is only a preview of the January 2023 issue of Silicon Chip. You can view 39 of the 112 pages in the full issue, including the advertisments. For full access, purchase the issue for $10.00 or subscribe for access to the latest issues. Articles in this series:
Items relevant to "Q Meter":
Items relevant to "Raspberry Pi Pico W BackPack":
Items relevant to "Active Subwoofer, Part 1":
Items relevant to "Noughts & Crosses game using just two modules":
Items relevant to "Noughts & Crosses Machine, Pt1":
Purchase a printed copy of this issue for $11.50. |
miniITX PCs
desktop power in a small package
Portable computers clearly have advantages and are invaluable for people who
must work while moving from place to place. I prefer desktop computers for
their higher performance, lower overall cost, ability to drive many monitors and
expandability, but they can take up a lot of space. Enter the Mini-ITX PC: the
power of a big desktop in a much smaller package.
M
ini-ITX PCs have been around for
some time; they are popular as
“home theatre PCs”, used for playing
videos and music in an entertainment
centre.
I had a large tower computer under
a desk because it wouldn’t fit on top,
taking up valuable leg room and making the desk feel cramped. So I decided
to build a compact PC to replace the
big tower.
I didn’t want to compromise on performance. After some research, I realised that just because the computer
would be smaller, that didn’t mean it
needed to be slow or lacking in RAM,
storage or graphics processing power.
There’s even room for water cooling if
you go about it the right way.
In building it, I learned many of the
tricks to constructing a good Mini-ITX
PC. I am writing this article on that
40
Silicon Chip
computer which is not only smaller
and faster, it’s also very quiet and
reliable.
After that success, I built several
other Mini-ITX computers, including
one to play music and videos that is
dead silent, so it doesn’t compromise
music listening enjoyment. We also
use one in our warehouse.
This article covers building one of
these mini computers from scratch,
explaining your options in choosing parts and some things to watch
out for. I was forced to change plans
when parts I bought wouldn’t fit; that
is something you’ll want to avoid.
ATX vs Mini-ITX
Full-size desktop computers
by Nicholas Vinen
Australia's electronics magazine
generally use ATX motherboards and
power supplies. These are based on a
standard published in 1995 by Intel
and updated several times since.
An ATX motherboard is 305 ×
244mm, and an ATX power supply is generally 150 × 86 × 140mm,
although the last dimension can vary
up to 230mm (usually for very high
power units).
Those dimensions dictate the minimum practical size of a case. ATX
cases are typically around 500mm
tall, 500mm deep and 210mm wide,
although they can be significantly
larger or a little more compact. That’s
a typical volume of about 50-60 litres.
Photo 1 shows a direct size comparison of a typical mid-size ATX case
(left) and two of the Mini-ITX cases I
used (middle & right).
A Mini-ITX motherboard is
siliconchip.com.au
considerably smaller than ATX at
170 × 170mm, and they are often
teamed up with SFX power supplies
that measure 100 × 125 × 63.5mm –
see Photo 2. The Corsair SFX power
supply shown there works really well
(it’s also available in a 750W version),
although it costs significantly more
than the more-powerful ATX supply
on the left.
Mini-ITX case sizes and volume
vary dramatically, from just a couple
of litres at the low end (about the size
of a thick notebook) to almost as large
as a mid-tower ATX case. The cases I
chose, shown in Photo 1, measure 325
× 166 × 310mm and 16.7 litres. I feel
that is about the sweet spot, although
you can go smaller if you want to.
Interestingly, case design can have
more to do with what fits than the size.
For example, there’s nowhere to mount
a water-cooling radiator in the larger
case on the left in Photo 1, while the
smaller ones fit a 120 × 240mm radiator nicely.
Photo 1: two Fractal Design Era Mini-ITX cases (right) and a low-cost Deep Cool
Tesseract ATX case on the left. I chose the Era cases mainly for their looks, as
one would be visible in my living room. I discovered they are pretty good to
work with, although there are more functional Mini-ITX cases for the money.
Mini-ITX limitations
So, what do you give up with
Mini-ITX+SFX compared to ATX? Not
a lot. You usually only get two RAM
slots on an ITX motherboard compared to four with ATX (see Photo 3),
although you can install 64GB of DDR4
RAM or 128GB of DDR5. You also get
fewer expansion slots but these days,
with at least two NVME slots on most
boards plus high-speed onboard USB
and networking, that won’t matter to
most users.
You also get less space in the case,
although you can still usually fit several SSDs (solid-state drives) and even
a traditional hard drive or two if you
need them.
Probably the most significant limitations are with the graphics processor unit (GPU). While you can build a
Mini-ITX PC with a high-end GPU, it is
not trivial to fit anything more potent
than a mid-range GPU like an Nvidia
RTX 3060 or an AMD RX 6600 XT. You
might also have trouble powering the
beefiest GPUs, as there are few SFX
power supplies above 750W.
You could choose a Mini-ITX case
that supports standard ATX power
supplies, in which case you could get
a 1000W+ supply. But dumping that
much heat into something the size of
a shoe box might not be a great idea!
The cases I used from the Fractal
Design Era series (www.fractal-design.
siliconchip.com.au
Photo 2: a 650W ATX power supply (left) and 600W SFX power supply (right).
ATX supplies up to about 1kW are available in the size shown here (or more,
but they are physically longer), while SFX supplies usually top out around
750W. That’s still plenty for most builds in a small case, though!
Photo 3: the
Mini-ITX
motherboard
I used. Note
how packed
it is with
components and
connectors! The
large space at
the top is for the
CPU and cooler.
Below that is
the chipset plus
NVME heatsink/
fan and the
expansion slot,
while the RAM
slots, SATA
and power
connectors are
on the right.
The I/O plate
dominates the
left side, the
same size as for
an ATX board.
Australia's electronics magazine
January 2023 41
com/products/cases/era/era-itx/) are
currently available from various suppliers for around $250-300 (some on
sale for $120 at the time of writing).
Many other similar cases are available,
and most of my advice applies to them
too. I will mention another great case I
have experience with towards the end
of the article.
Choosing a Mini-ITX case
I chose the Era for a few reasons.
One was the support for both SFX
and ATX power supplies, although
I learned while building them that
you have much more room to breathe
(and install hard drives) if you take
the SFX option. Other cases that offer
that choice will be similarly squashed
if you go with the ATX option.
As mentioned earlier, the biggest
problem with SFX power supplies is
the cost; you can get some great power
supplies, so you aren’t compromising
much in terms of performance as long
as 750W is enough.
The first thing you will need to do
if you want to build a Mini-ITX PC is
decide on what parts you want to put
into it and start shopping for cases
that will fit them all. The cases vary so
much in size and design that finding
the right one will take a while.
For a start, if you want to water cool
your CPU or GPU, you’ll need a case
that fits a radiator or two. The largest radiator that will fit in most MiniITX cases is 280 × 140mm, although
a maximum of 240 × 120mm is more
common, and some will only fit 120
× 120mm or none at all.
With cases that can fit a radiator, you
almost certainly give up some other
capability if you install one. For example, the radiator might limit the maximum length of the GPU or the ability to
use an ATX power supply. So check all
that carefully. I have even seen cases
where the radiator interferes with tall
RAM sticks! Use low-profile non-RGB
RAM if possible, to ensure it will fit
(see Photo 5).
Note: while we don’t recommend it,
you can also consider removing the
Photo 4: the Scythe Shuriken 2
costs around $100 and sits
only 58mm tall. To get
any more compact
than this, you
pretty much need a
passive cooler and
rely on case airflow.
You might also need
low-profile RAM
sticks; sometimes,
less tall DIMMs are
required to clear other
things that might be in the
case, depending on its exact
configuration.
heatsink from the RAM if you need
extra space, as most RAM does not
get hot enough to need the heatsink
for dissipation.
Once you have found a case you
think is perfect, download and read
its manual. There should be a section
discussing what will fit and hopefully explain any such limitations.
Verify that one of your parts won’t
interfere with fitting another; if necessary, download their manuals too,
to determine their exact dimensions.
Doing this now will save you a headache later!
If you are air cooling the CPU (generally the cheaper and more sensible
option), check the maximum cooler
height supported by your case, which
is usually limited by its internal width.
Low-profile CPU coolers exist to suit
compact cases, but they typically have
worse cooling performance and are
noisier. If you’re willing to potentially
sacrifice some performance, you can
also look into a passive cooling setup.
I couldn’t find a standard 120mm
tower cooler that would fit in the Era
case, but I did find a Noctua 92mm
tower cooler that fits just fine and is
extremely quiet, which I used in my
later home theatre build (there’s a
photo of it below). Another option is
something like the Scythe Shuriken
2, which also has a 92mm fan but it’s
horizontal, making the whole thing
only 58mm tall, so it will fit in quite
compact cases - see Photo 4.
Check the GPU size limitations carefully. One of the nice things about the
Era case is that it will fit a “2.2-slot”
GPU up to 295mm long (depending on
the power supply type and location).
The EVGA 3070 XC3 GPU I ended up
using is a 2.2-slot design that’s 285mm
long, and it just fits with an SFX power
supply in there. And I mean “just” –
more on that later.
I suspect the considerably more
powerful EVGA 3080 XC3 is the same
size. So you could possibly squeeze
one of those into the same case, but
they were unobtainium at the time
I was building this computer. Other
Mini-ITX cases can limit GPU width
to 2.0 slots or less, so check that.
You can get two NVME SSDs onto
most Mini-ITX motherboards (possibly three). They are very fast and
come in capacities up to about 2TB,
although the 512GB and 1TB models
are much better value. So unless you
need more than 4TB of storage space,
you don’t need any external storage.
If you need external storage, check
what your proposed case will fit and
whether you lose any of those slots
based on other things like space for a
radiator or ATX power supply.
Building it
Generally, it’s easiest to attach the
CPU, RAM and NVME SSD(s) to the
motherboard before you install it in
Photo 5: these DIMMs are good value for money
and perform pretty well, but their shape causes
many clearance problems! This is typical of RAM
with RGB LEDs, as they are usually mounted in a
housing at the top of the actual DIMM. RGB DIMMs
look nice (assuming you can see into the case) but
cause fitment problems even in full-size ATX cases.
Do yourself a favour and avoid them.
42
Silicon Chip
Australia's electronics magazine
siliconchip.com.au
What to look for when choosing a Mini-ITX case
∎ What size/volume do you want?
∎ Do you like how it looks?
∎ What size of power supply does it accept?
∎ Will it fit your proposed CPU cooler (radiator/tower cooler)?
∎ What size GPU will it fit, considering width, length and height and choice of
power supply and CPU cooler? You need to have a specific GPU in mind and
check its dimensions.
∎ Does it have space for extra fans for case airflow, and if so, how are they
configured (intake/exhaust/etc)?
∎ If you need off-motherboard storage, how many and what size of SSDs or
hard drives will it fit?
∎ What sort of front-panel I/O does it have? USB 3.0, USB4, Thunderbolt?
How many ports?
the case. If using an air cooler, you
can probably also mount that first.
This will give you an ‘assembly’ you
can drop straight into the case and
then wire up.
After that, it’s mainly just a matter
of installing the power supply, plugging in the GPU (if you aren’t using
onboard graphics), plugging in any
external storage, connecting any water
cooling hardware, and you’re ready to
fire it up.
Photo 6 shows the parts I initially
chose for my first Mini-ITX computer.
They all fit in the case, although I discovered later that the fit of the video
card/GPU (shown at the bottom of that
photo) was a bit too tight. I ended up
swapping it for the slightly smaller
but more powerful (and unfortunately,
more expensive) EVGA GPU I already
mentioned.
Next to the case are the boxes for
the motherboard and CPU (on top).
The 240mm all-in-one (AIO) CPU
water cooler is to the right, with the
600W SFX power supply box on top.
The 32GB of RAM (2 × 16GB) pack is
in the middle, with the 1TB NVME
SSD to the right and the GPU in the
foreground.
I got these from a few different retailers, all of which have good prices and
service. There are links to their websites at the end of the article.
By now, some of this hardware is no
longer cutting edge, so you will probably want to do some research. However, replicating my build is still possible, and some parts are now cheaper.
The mesh panel next to the case in
Photo 6 came with it, to be used in place
of the (elegant) solid timber lid. The
timber top is not great for high-power
builds as it reduces the exhaust airflow.
This case is designed to intake air
into the slots around the base, draw it
up past the GPU/motherboard/CPU,
and exhaust it out the top – a clever
configuration that works pretty well.
The timber top (or glass in other
colour versions of the same case) will
be fine for a basic ‘office’ PC.
Photo 6: all the parts I used to build my first Mini-ITX PC. The only real change was the GPU (at bottom); while I got it
into the case (just!), the fans rubbed on the bottom, so I ended up swapping it for a more powerful but slightly smaller
EVGA brand NVIDIA RTX 3070 that just squeezed into the available space.
siliconchip.com.au
Australia's electronics magazine
January 2023 43
CPU choice
I chose a Ryzen 5600X for this computer because of its thermal design
power (TDP) rating of 65W, along
with very good performance. While
the cooling system chosen could handle a 105W TDP CPU, that would be
an extra 50W+ that the power supply
would have to deliver and the cooling
system would have to remove, for only
a modest increase in performance.
At the time (and possibly still
today), AMD CPUs were considerably more efficient than comparable
Intel parts, which could pull 200W or
more under full load. The GPU already
draws and dissipates a lot of power, so
I didn’t want to overload the system
with heat.
You could also build a Mini-ITX
PC with a newer Ryzen 7000-series
or Intel 13th-gen Core series CPU if
you’re willing to spend more for higher
performance. The only real difference
will be in how the CPU mounts on the
motherboard.
Assembly
Photo 7: the side panel is held on by magnets and comes off easily. You need to
remove the vertical brace to do most work. This brace can be used to mount two
2.5-inch SSDs or a single 3.5-inch HDD, but I didn’t need it. The two brackets
at upper right are for vertically mounting ATX (upper) or SFX (lower) power
supplies. Note the small inbuilt IEC mains extension cable.
Photo 8: with all the brackets removed, we now have good access to the inside
of the case. It comes with one rear exhaust fan, but it’s pretty small at around
80mm across, so you’ll want to keep it running at a low speed to avoid noise.
You will want to install two 120mm exhaust fans at the top, by themselves or on
a radiator, as they will do the bulk of the cooling.
44
Silicon Chip
Australia's electronics magazine
Photo 7 shows what you see when
you remove the side panel of the case,
which, in this case, is easy – just pull
it to the side, then up. Most other
cases will not have that internal side
brace; I removed it early on and only
refitted it after I finished installing
all the parts. You can mount two 2.5inch drives (or one 3.5-inch) on it, but
I didn’t need that feature. I only kept
it for rigidity.
Photo 8 shows the case with the
brace and both power supply brackets
removed – much better! The bundle of
cables on the right are for the power
switch and front-panel USB ports; the
wires are far too long, which is quite
annoying and caused slight problems
that I eventually solved after some
head-scratching.
One difference between typical
ATX and Mini-ITX cases is that, with
the former, the power supply usually
mounts so that its mains input socket
and power switch are externally accessible via a cut-out in the rear of the
case. But most Mini-ITX cases mount
the power supply internally, hence the
IEC mains extension cable.
It plugs into the power supply, and
the external power cable plugs into a
socket built into the rear of the case,
visible at lower left. The ATX supply’s
power switch is not externally accessible, although that isn’t a big deal.
siliconchip.com.au
Note how the rear of the case has
three large cut-outs. These allow
access to the back of the motherboard
when installed, which is very helpful
as most current motherboards have
at least one NVME storage slot on the
back. They also give you access to the
CPU cooler mounting screws, which
often need to be removed to install a
custom bracket for a high-end CPU
cooler (air or water).
Photo 9 shows the parts that came
in the box of the 240mm AIO CPU
cooler I purchased. It’s called ‘all-inone’ because the radiator, pump, tubes
and water block are supplied as a single unit, pre-filled with coolant. The
pump is on the hoses near the radiator;
it’s more typical to find it integrated
with the water block.
Two low-noise fans are supplied
for cooling the radiator, along with
all the necessary mounting hardware
and some spare coolant, for a few years
down the track, when it might start
getting low.
I am happy with the performance of
this cooling solution and would recommend it to others. It is near-silent
unless you are very close to it, and it
not only cools the CPU well, it also
serves to exhaust hot air from the case
(more on how important that is later).
Still, the air cooling solution I tried
Photo 9: everything shown here comes in the Pure Loop AIO package. The fans
mount on the radiator using the supplied hardware in either ‘pull’ or ‘push’
configuration. Either way will work; it mainly depends on whether you want
air to flow into or out of the case at that point. The pack at lower left includes
thermal paste in a syringe plus mounting brackets to suit various CPU types.
later is much cheaper and probably
preferable for many builders.
In Photo 10, I have installed the
radiator in the top of the case, with
the fans underneath blowing up.
That was easy, as the top of the case
is removable.
It is at this point that I discovered
it’s impractical to use an ATX power
supply in this case if you have a
240mm radiator; note how the radiator and fans occupy the space at upper
right, forcing the power supply bracket
to be installed on one of the lower
three screw holes. I don’t believe the
manual or specifications sheet mentioned that. Good thing I chose an SFX
power supply!
Photo 10: the Pure Loop AIO, installed in the case, with the
fans blowing air up and out. The tubes are a bit too long as
this cooler has to work on larger ATX systems too.
Photo 11: the CPU and RAM have been installed, and the
fan/heatsink has been moved out of the way to reveal one
of the NVME M.2 storage slots. There’s another one on the
underside of the board but this one has better cooling, plus it
has a direct connection to the CPU, so it should be faster.
siliconchip.com.au
Australia's electronics magazine
January 2023 45
Photo 12: I removed the top of the case and lifted the AIO out to give myself
more room to mount the motherboard. I ran the CPU power cable under the
motherboard before installing it since it would be hard later. This is a modular
power supply, so you plug in the DC cables as you route them, making life
easier. It also reduces clutter, as you don’t need to install cables you won’t use.
Photo 13: with the remaining power supply DC cables installed and the case
top/AIO refitted, the case is getting more crowded. Still, assembly is almost
complete. I moved the power supply bracket down to its lowest position so air
could flow freely to the right-hand upper exhaust fan.
Next, I inserted the CPU in the motherboard’s ZIF socket (Photo 11) and
removed the NVME/chipset heatsink/
fan to reveal the upper NVME socket.
By this point, I had also installed the
two DDR4 DIMMs (32GB of RAM).
After installing the NVME SSD and
replacing the heatsink/fan, I mounted
the motherboard in the case using the
supplied screws (Photo 12).
However, I routed the power supply
wires to the CPU power input at upper
left under the motherboard first. You
46
Silicon Chip
can see that I have also installed the
SFX power supply via the supplied
bracket and plugged in the mains input
extension.
In Photo 13, I have installed all
the remaining power supply cables,
bundled them up out of the way and
plugged in some of the front panel I/O
cables to the motherboard. I used spare
holes in the power supply bracket to
attach cable ties to keep the long power
supply wires in check.
Another advantage of SFX supplies
Australia's electronics magazine
for small builds is that they usually
come with shorter cables. I discovered
that after building some other similar
computers using ATX power supplies,
the cable slack took up a lot of the spare
space inside the case and routing the
wiring became quite tricky!
In Photo 14, I have applied a thin
layer of thermal paste to the CPU (it
came with the cooler). Some people
like to put a blob or two in the middle
and allow the pressure from the cold
plate to spread it out, but I prefer this
method as it guarantees even distribution. Note the brackets on either side
of the CPU – they came with the AIO
and are specific to it, replacing the
standard AMD brackets.
In Photo 15, I have clamped the
AIO cold plate down on top of the
CPU, installed the GPU (visible at the
bottom) and strapped all the unused
captive cables to other things to keep
them out of the way. The goal was to
keep plenty of space for cooling air to
flow past the GPU and components on
the motherboard.
Don’t forget to remove the plastic
film from the bottom of the cooler
before installing it! The cooler won’t
work properly and the CPU will enter
thermal throttling under load.
Note the slots in the bottom of the
case for cool air to be drawn in (visible in the adjacent photos). There is
a chamber at the bottom of the case
with a perforated section between it
and the GPU area to allow fresh air
intake.
This is where I ran into a snag: the
GPU sagged a little bit under its own
weight, and its fans touched that perforated section. As soon as the computer powered up, it made a horrible
noise as the fans tried to rotate against
the plastic.
My solution was to get some small
adhesive rubber pads from Bunnings
and stick them between the GPU’s
plastic shroud and the bottom of the
case, lifting the GPU enough for the
fans to spin freely.
That worked, but sometimes when
I switched the computer on, the
fans would still strike the case. So, I
replaced the 5600 XT with the EVGA
XC3 RTX 3070. I chose it because it
was a hair thinner than the 5600 XT
while being quite a bit more powerful.
I still needed those rubber pads to
prevent its fans from rubbing, but that
completely fixed it, and I haven’t had
a problem since.
siliconchip.com.au
All that was left after Photo 15 was
to refit the side brace, reattach the side
panels, fire the system up and install
the operating system.
The only other catch I ran into was
that some of the front panel cables had
become caught between the power
supply and the front of the case, causing the power button to act as if it was
pressed all the time. That threw me at
first, as the system refused to power
up (because the button was already
‘pressed’). But once I figured it out and
freed those cables, it worked perfectly
and has since.
Screen 1 shows the result of a
benchmark I ran shortly after building
the computer, showing that despite
its size and lack of ‘high-end’ parts,
it was still in the 91st percentile in
terms of overall CPU performance at
the time.
Thermal tweaks
Besides the fans on the GPU, which
serve only to cool it (circulating and
heating the air around it), there are
only four fans in this system: the small
one on the motherboard that cools the
SSD and chipset, a small rear exhaust
fan that doesn’t do much, and the two
passing air over the AIO radiator.
That means the AIO radiator fans
also serve as ‘case fans’ to draw air
up through the slots in the bottom,
past the GPU, chipset and regulators
on the motherboard, then through the
CPU radiator and out the top. They are
vital to the system operating at a reasonable temperature.
The RX 5600 XT I initially chose
could draw up to 150W (about three
times what the CPU does under a typical load). But the RTX 3070 can consume around 250W; I even bumped it
up to around 275W to improve its performance. That leads to the air drawn
in getting quite warm before it each
reaches the motherboard or radiator.
Along with the CPU, motherboard,
SSD and other parts, the system can
draw 350W or more under load.
Despite that, system temperatures
remain reasonable, with the CPU sitting at around 50-60°C under load,
the motherboard at about 40-50°C and
the GPU core around 60-70°C (at an
ambient temperature of 23°C). This
does have the effect of the computer
acting like a small (albeit relatively
quiet) space heater with all that hot
air being ejected from the top. But it
will run like that all day.
siliconchip.com.au
Photo 14: this close-up view shows some details that aren’t apparent in earlier
photos and also shows how I smeared thermal paste on the CPU. I could be
accused of using a bit too much, but it’s better than too little! I tied cables up to
keep them out of the airflow path as much as possible and that also made my
life easier when I had to plug cables into the motherboard.
Photo 15: assembly is basically complete. Note how I had to loop and tie the
water tubes (highlighted in yellow) and how little space there is for the GPU
at the bottom. Getting it in and out was not easy, especially given the multiple
power cables that needed to be plugged into it (visible at lower right). Note how
the GPU heatsink occupies the entire length of the case.
Australia's electronics magazine
January 2023 47
Photo 16: this Noctua
NH-U9S is not cheap at
around $120, but it is
an almost ideal solution
in this style of Mini-ITX
case. It provides decent cooling
in nearly complete silence and
will fit a small case; it’s just not
suitable for super-compact jobs.
There was a trick to achieving that.
By default, the motherboard adjusts
the CPU fan speed based on CPU temperature. Because this cooling system
is effective enough to keep the CPU
at a low temperature even under load
with a low fan speed, the fans would
not speed up, even if the GPU was
dumping a lot of heat into the case.
While the system never ‘melted
down’, it ran hotter than I liked.
The solution was to go into the
BIOS and get it to use the “system
temperature” to control the CPU fan
speed instead. That temperature is
sensed at the chipset, so when the
GPU starts heating the air inside the
case, that also heats the chipset. The
fans will quickly ramp up and provide the airflow necessary to remove
the GPU heat and keep the motherboard and regulators cool. It works
surprisingly well.
The other tweak I made was to
replace the timber top panel with the
supplied mesh panel. Again, the system didn’t melt down before, but that
dropped the GPU and motherboard
temperatures by about 10°C and made
the system run quieter under load. So
I consider it a worthwhile change.
a radiator at the top of the case,
I installed two normal low-noise
120mm computer fans in the top panel
and again set them to be controlled by
the system temperature. Because those
fans are much thinner than a radiator,
I could raise the power supply bracket
to fit a lower-cost regular ATX power
supply (it’s a different computer, but
Photo 17 shows the arrangement).
Other Mini-ITX cases
Sometime after building these systems, I needed a new computer for
my home office and decided to see
how powerful a computer I could jam
into a Mini-ITX case. I did a lot of
research using the experience gained
from building in the Era cases and settled on the MetallicGear Neo Mini V2
(https://metallicgear.com/products/
Neo-Mini-V2).
It is somewhat larger than the Era,
although still quite a bit smaller than
a Mid-ATX case, and has a tempered-
glass side panel so you can see the
innards. It was also a lot less expensive
than the Era cases at $99, although it
isn’t quite as stylish.
I chose this case because you can
mount two radiators in it, one 120
x 120mm at the rear and one 240 x
120mm on the right side (looking at
the front). Other cases can mount two
radiators, with one at the top, but the
computer was going under a desk, and
a top exhaust would cause warm air
to bounce off the desk and wash over
my legs (good in winter, not so much
in summer).
I used similar parts to the build
documented here, except the GPU
is a monstrous water-cooled NVIDIA
RTX 3090 putting out about 400W
under full load (slightly more than
its stock power level). It came with
an integrated 240mm radiator, which
I mounted to exhaust through the side
of the case, with dual 140mm intake
fans at the front – see Photo 18.
Air-cooled system
I built a similar system for my ‘home
theatre’ using the Noctua ‘tower’ air
cooler with a 92mm fan shown in
Photo 16. I fitted it to the CPU/motherboard combination before putting it
in the case as that was easier. As all
that system does is play music and
videos, this handles the CPU dissipation just fine.
Because that system doesn’t have
48
Silicon Chip
Photo 17: you can see how much more easily the Mini-ITX board with the
Shuriken 2 fits into this Era case, despite using a much larger ATX power
supply. Note also the mess of cables at lower right due to ATX supplies coming
with longer cables. I used a smaller and less expensive video card in this system
as it is intended for basic office tasks.
Australia's electronics magazine
siliconchip.com.au
Screen 1:
the CPU
temperature is a
very reasonable
62°C with
all six-cores
loaded due to
the generouslysized water
cooling system.
Fresh air to cool the GPU comes into
the front of the case through mesh-
covered side slots, passes through its
radiator and immediately exits the
case, so it can’t heat anything else up.
Similarly, some of that air coming into
the front goes into the rear-mounted
CPU radiator and exits the case. Airflow through the case keeps the power
supply and motherboard cool.
The result is a very high level of performance in a small space (380 x 355 x
190mm; 25.6L). While plenty of warm
air comes out, it is blown away from
me; the only side-effect I notice is that
the room gets warmer after a while.
If you wanted to build a similar
computer to sit on top of a desk, you
could choose the top exhaust option
using a suitable case; that might work
even better.
Overall, MetallicGear Mini-ITX
cases (and the related brand, Phanteks)
seem well-designed and well-built and
are good value for money. Still, there
are numerous manufacturers of good
small form factor (SFF) cases, including Mini-ITX, so it’s worth doing some
research and browsing before deciding
which one to purchase.
Unfortunately, I can no longer find
this case for sale, but similar Metallic
Gear Mini-ITX cases are available.
and came up with the following estimates for a basic but decent system:
$100 for the case, $280 for a Ryzen
5600G CPU with onboard graphics,
$150 for a B450 motherboard, $100
for 16GB of DDR4 RAM, $150 for a
1TB SSD and $100 for a power supply.
That totals almost exactly $900 for a
‘reasonable’ system without a discrete
GPU. A system with a discrete GPU
will be much better for tasks like playing games or 3D rendering, but you’ll
need to add the cost of that GPU to the
$900 base price estimate. In that case,
you might want a faster CPU, better
motherboard and more RAM, adding
perhaps another $200 to the total cost.
While you can build a Mini-ITX
system for under $900, the result will
be compromised in some areas (eg, a
slower CPU and less memory and/or
storage). But for typical use you could
likely get away with a cheaper CPU.
For your average user, a Mini-ITX
PC will do everything a full-size desktop will do in a much smaller package.
You can put together a computer like
this for around $800-2000, depending
on your chosen parts.
I checked the cost of parts from
Umart (see below) as I am writing this
Photo 18: this system built
in a MetallicGear Neo
Mini V2 case consumes
over 500W but still
technically has a ‘small
form factor’! While it is
a bit larger than most
Mini-ITX systems, it’s still
about half the volume of
a typical ATX case. The
motherboard ends around
where you can see the top
of the DIMMs; the space
to the right (at front of the
case) is occupied by the
GPU radiator; the small
CPU radiator is visible
at lower left. Amazingly,
it runs cool due to the
carefully considered layout.
siliconchip.com.au
Australia's electronics magazine
Conclusion
Remember that those prices don’t
include a keyboard, mouse or monitor,
although you might already have those
if you upgrade from an existing system.
Where to buy parts
I have found the vendors below
reasonably reliable and offer fast and
inexpensive delivery within Australia. Compare the prices as sometimes
one will offer a product cheaper than
others.
Umart (NE Queensland):
www.umart.com.au
Scorptec (Clayton, Vic with stores
throughout Australia):
www.scorptec.com.au
mwave (Lidcombe, NSW):
www.mwave.com.au
You can also find good parts deals
on Amazon (www.amazon.com.au)
and eBay (www.ebay.com.au – caveat
SC
emptor!)
49
|